Get Transgressing the Bounds: Subversive Enterprises among the PDF

History 1

By Louise A. Breen

ISBN-10: 0195138007

ISBN-13: 9780195138009

This examine deals a brand new interpretation of the Puritan "Antinomian" controversy and a skillful research of its wider and long-term social and cultural importance. Breen argues that controversy either mirrored and fostered higher questions of id that will persist in Puritan New England through the seventeenth century. a few concerns mentioned the following comprise the life of individualism in a society that valued conformity and the reaction of participants of an inward-looking, localistic tradition to these between them of a extra "cosmopolitan" nature. vital to Breen's research is the traditional and Honorable Artillery corporation of Massachusetts, an elite social membership that attracted a heterogeneous but sought after club, and whose variety contrasted with the social and non secular beliefs of the cultural majority.

Show description

Read Online or Download Transgressing the Bounds: Subversive Enterprises among the Puritan Elite in Massachusetts, 1630-1692 PDF

Similar history_1 books

New PDF release: Origins: Selected Letters of Charles Darwin, 1822-1859.

Charles Darwin replaced the path of recent concept by way of setting up the root of evolutionary biology. This attention-grabbing choice of letters, bargains a glimpse of his day-by-day stories, clinical observations, own issues and friendships. starting with an enthralling set of letters on the age of twelve, via his college years in Edinburgh and Cambridge as much as the book of his most famed paintings, at the starting place of Species in 1859, those letters chart probably the most interesting classes of Darwin's lifestyles, together with the voyage of the Beagle and next reviews which led him to advance his concept of common choice.

Extra resources for Transgressing the Bounds: Subversive Enterprises among the Puritan Elite in Massachusetts, 1630-1692

Example text

63 Wheelwright’s greatest failing in Winthrop’s eyes was that he evinced hostility, not “tendernesse of heart,” toward those whom he described as works-righteous. ” Colonists who “professe their faith in Christ only, etc. ”64 the antinomian moment 31 John Cotton, unlike Wheelwright, was universally regarded as mild of manner. Yet in exchanges with orthodox ministers even he was accused of being insufficiently charitable, for his views were thought to deprive professed Christians of the peace of mind that might come from right living and striving after faith.

And Cotton’s tactic of focusing on the issue of family loyalty obscured the more substantive question that Hutchinson, Savage, and Gibbons had raised: Why must the individual always submit to the will of the group? If Hutchinson’s defenders focused on the church’s obligation to satisfy the needs of one errant member, the Massachusetts ministers believed that the airing of “grave” theological errors, while possibly edifying to Hutchinson, should be concluded as soon as possible because such discussion might pollute the minds of spectators (especially women).

110 Once consensus was reached, the clergymen believed, the individual who scrupled it must either capitulate quickly or face public humiliation. ”111 The framers of orthodoxy, paying heed to the remarks made by men like Savage, Stoddard, and Hutchinson, worried that the diverse positions forced together under the antinomian umbrella would destroy the unity desperately needed in a new plantation dedicated to right religion. The proliferation of antinomian ideas, it was feared, might embolden people to chart their own ecclesiastical destinies and to throw off societal responsibilities.

Download PDF sample

Transgressing the Bounds: Subversive Enterprises among the Puritan Elite in Massachusetts, 1630-1692 by Louise A. Breen

by Anthony

Rated 4.86 of 5 – based on 37 votes